Islamorada Fish Co 81532 Overseas Highway Islamorada (305) 664-9271 http://www.fishcompany.com/ We had heard good things about this place from a few people but got a little nervous walking in and it was empty and we were the only people sitting for dinner,  it was the lull before busy season so we gave it a try.   The food was really really good and we enjoyed everything we had,  the Oysters were great, the Stone Crab was fantastic and the Dolphin was also good.  I had the Conch Salad and it was ok but nothing like the Bahamas that I hoped for.  The service was good and we actually met a very cool couple from PA that we talked to for  couple hours after eating.  Fun times